Justice and Courts
Civil Mediation and ADR Methods
Resolving a dispute does not necessarily require a trial. In Quebec, Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) methods—including mediation and arbitration—often provide a faster, more flexible, and less costly out-of-court solution. Here’s how they work and how they differ from family mediation.
On this page
Going to court is not always the best or only way to resolve a conflict. Quebec law encourages parties to first consider amicable solutions. This is the purpose of Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) methods, a family of tools that includes negotiation, mediation, and arbitration. For official information, the Quebec government’s Justice portal presents these mechanisms and their procedures. This fact sheet explains what civil mediation is, how it differs from arbitration and family mediation, its benefits, its process, and the mediation offered in small claims cases.
What are ADR methods?
ADR methods refer to all ways of resolving a dispute other than through a judgment imposed at the end of a trial. The general idea is to give parties greater control over the solution. They primarily include:
- negotiation, where parties discuss directly, sometimes with the help of their lawyers;
- mediation, where a neutral third party facilitates discussion without imposing a decision;
- arbitration, where a third party hears the parties and renders a decision.
These methods can be used before initiating legal action, in parallel, or even during ongoing proceedings. Quebec law encourages parties to consider these options before resorting to the courts.
Using an ADR method does not require waiving your rights. If no agreement is reached, it is generally still possible to proceed before the courts.
Civil Mediation
Civil mediation is a voluntary process in which a mediator, a neutral and impartial third party, helps parties communicate, identify their interests, and seek an agreement. Key point: the mediator does not decide the dispute. They do not impose any decision. It is the parties who, if they wish, agree on a solution.
Civil mediation can cover a wide variety of disputes: neighbor disputes, commercial disagreements, contractual issues, conflicts between partners, etc. It largely relies on the confidentiality of exchanges, which fosters frank discussions.
Arbitration
Arbitration is distinctly different from mediation. Here, parties entrust an arbitrator (or a panel of arbitrators) with the task of hearing their case and rendering a decision. Depending on what has been agreed upon and the applicable framework, this decision can be binding on the parties. Arbitration is more akin to a private trial: there is a hearing, arguments, and a decision.
This method is often chosen in commercial cases or when parties want a decision from a third party but outside the public judicial system. The choice between mediation and arbitration depends on what the parties are seeking: to maintain control over the solution, or to obtain a decision.
| Criterion | Mediation | Arbitration |
|---|---|---|
| Who decides? | The parties themselves | The arbitrator |
| Role of the third party | Facilitate discussion | Hear and decide |
| Outcome | Agreement, if parties concur | Arbitrator’s decision |
| Flexibility | High | Structured, similar to a trial |
| Party control | Strong | More limited |
Not to be confused with family mediation
An important point to avoid confusion: civil mediation and family mediation are not the same thing. Family mediation specifically addresses issues arising from separation or divorce—child custody, parenting time, support payments, division of assets—and is subject to a specific program in Quebec. Civil mediation, on the other hand, concerns other types of disputes (neighbors, business, contracts, etc.).
If your situation involves family matters, please consult our fact sheet on Family Mediation. For disputes of lower value, also see Small Claims.
Benefits of Mediation
Why consider mediation rather than a trial? Several advantages are often highlighted:
- generally shorter timelines than a trial;
- often lower costs;
- greater flexibility in potential solutions;
- confidentiality of discussions;
- possible preservation of relationships, an important asset between neighbors or business partners.
These advantages are not suitable for all situations. Some disputes require a judicial decision, for example, when a matter of principle needs to be settled. However, mediation remains an avenue to seriously consider in many cases.
Mediation relies on good faith and a willingness to discuss. It works best when parties are ready to listen and seek common ground, even if their initial positions are far apart.
The Mediation Process
Although each mediation is unique, the process often follows major steps. As an indication:
- an initial contact and the parties’ agreement to use mediation;
- one or more sessions, where each party presents their perspective and interests;
- the exploration of solutions, facilitated by the mediator;
- if an agreement emerges, the written formalization of the agreement.
The mediator ensures the framework and balance of exchanges but does not take sides. An agreement reached is binding on the parties who accept it, and it is prudent to verify its scope and, if necessary, the steps to give it greater enforceability.
Mediation in Small Claims Court
At the Small Claims Division, a mediation session may be offered to parties to try to resolve their dispute before the hearing. This mediation aims to quickly find a solution acceptable to all, within a simple framework and without excessive formalities. The specific procedures depend on the case and the court.
This possibility is part of a broader desire to promote amicable settlement, including within the judicial system. For an overview of how courts operate, consult our topic Justice and Courts.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is civil mediation?+
Civil mediation is a dispute resolution method where a neutral and impartial third party, the mediator, helps parties discuss and seek an agreement themselves. The mediator does not decide the dispute: the parties make the decision.
What is the difference between mediation and arbitration?+
In mediation, parties retain control and seek an agreement with the help of a mediator who does not decide. In arbitration, an arbitrator hears the parties and renders a decision that, depending on the case, may be binding on them. Arbitration is more akin to a private trial.
Is civil mediation the same as family mediation?+
No. Family mediation addresses issues related to separation and children and is part of a specific program. Civil mediation concerns other types of disputes, for example, between neighbors, in business, or in contractual matters.
Is mediation available in small claims?+
Yes. In the Small Claims Division, a mediation session may be offered to parties to try to resolve their dispute before the hearing. The procedures depend on the case and the court.
Is an agreement reached through mediation binding?+
An agreement concluded in mediation is binding on the parties who accept it. Depending on the case, it can be put in writing and, in certain situations, steps can be taken to give it greater enforceability. It is prudent to verify the scope of your agreement.
Sources
- Quebec Code of Civil Procedure (provisions on private ADR methods).
- Justice – Government of Quebec (justice.gouv.qc.ca).
- Mediation in the Small Claims Division – Quebec Ministry of Justice.
- Family Mediation Program – Government of Quebec.
This fact sheet provides general legal information updated as of July 6, 2026. It does not constitute legal advice. Each situation is unique: for tailored advice, consult a lawyer or an accredited mediator.
Besoin d’un avocat pour votre situation ?
Trouvez le bon avocat en droit de la famille au Québec — gratuitement, en toute confidentialité et sans engagement.
Trouver mon avocat